By Nick Baumann
Mother Jones Blog
The White House acknowledged in a court filing last night that it no
longer has backup tapes of email from between March 1 and May 22, 2003,
a period that includes the beginning of the Iraq war.
Yesterday's filing (PDF)  is the latest development in the ongoing
White House emails lawsuit, in which two non-profits, Citizens for
Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) and the National Security
Archive (NSA), are suing to force the administration to recover any
missing emails and institute a more effective email archiving system.
(For the full story on the missing emails, check out our missing White
House emails index. ) The filing comes on the heels of several
seemingly contradictory statements by administration officials about
whether the allegedly missing emails are available on backup tapes. The
court had asked the administration to clear up the confusion by clearly
stating which backup tapes it does and does not have for the period
between March 2003 and October 2005.
In their filing, administration officials claim they have 438 backup
tapes for the period between May 23, 2003 and September 29, 2003. The
White House stopped its foolish policy of recycling backup tapes in
early October 2003, so all the backup tapes made after that date are
supposedly preserved.some 60,000 of them. But even the emergency
recovery backup tapes the White House does have are far from a
fool-proof source for recovering missing emails. Any email that arrived
and was deleted in between backups wouldn't be preserved, since backup
tapes take a digital "picture" of the data on a drive at a given time.
And while that problem applies to all the backups, it's especially
concerning for the period between May 23 and September 29, 2003, for
which the White House says it has 438 backup tapes. That is a low number
of backup tapes per day for an entity as large as the Executive Office
of the President, so backups may not have been made for all offices in
the EOP on all days during that time. Even if backups were made every
day for every component of the EOP, emails could still escape archiving
if they were sent, received, and deleted in between backups.
All this doesn't even begin to address the period between March 1 and
May 22, for which we now know for certain that no backup tapes exist. In
an email to the press earlier today, Meredith Fuchs, the general counsel
for the National Security Archive, wrote:
It seems clear now that the e-mail backups are spotty and that there
is no guarantee that there are backup tapes for all of EOP during
the period of concern, March 2003-October 2005. There are no tapes
from earlier than May 23, 2003. So, anything deleted from the EOP
network prior to May 23, 2003 (particularly between March 2003 and
may 23, 2003) is missing from the back-up tapes.
The plaintiffs are hoping that the judge will issue a ruling forcing the
White House to copy email archive .pst files from all sorts of
electronic sources, including hard drives and portable devices, in an
attempt to insure no more emails go missing. The administration's
admission that its backup tape library is incomplete may be the
justification the judge needs to do just that. A ruling is expected
soon, but Fuchs told me she's worried it will all be for naught. "Here
we are two and a half years after they realized there was a problem and
they are not in a position to say whether anything is missing or not,"
Fuchs says. "I honestly think they are just trying to run out the clock,
and then it's a huge mess. Maybe the court's going to act quickly and
we'll get better preservation. That's what we'll hope for at this
Attend Black Hat USA, August 2-7 in Las Vegas,
the world's premier technical event for ICT security experts.
Featuring 40 hands-on training courses and 80 Briefings
presentations with lots of new content and new tools.
Network with 4,000 delegates from 50 nations.
Visit product displays by 30 top sponsors in
a relaxed setting. http://www.blackhat.com